Why is Canberra the capital of Australia? The rivalry that built a city from scratch
Canberra exists because Sydney and Melbourne couldn't agree. How a constitutional compromise, a sheep paddock and a Chicago architect couple created Australia's capital.
Visitors to Australia are often surprised to learn that the capital isn’t Sydney, the largest and best-known city, or Melbourne, the second largest. It’s Canberra, a planned city of around 470,000 people tucked into the hills of the Australian Capital Territory, about three hours’ drive south-west of Sydney.
Canberra is the capital because of a compromise. At Federation, neither Sydney nor Melbourne would accept the other as the seat of government, so the founders agreed to build a new city somewhere between them. What followed was two decades of surveying, lobbying and argument, an international design competition and the slow construction of a capital in a sheep paddock. The story says a great deal about how Australia was put together.
The colonies and their rivalry
Before 1901 there was no country called Australia, at least not in a legal sense. There were six separate British colonies: New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland, South Australia, Western Australia and Tasmania. Each had its own parliament, laws, tariffs and railways, sometimes built to different gauges.
The two largest, New South Wales and Victoria, were also rivals. Sydney was the oldest settlement and the capital of the founding colony. Melbourne, transformed by the gold rushes of the 1850s, had become the larger and richer city by the late nineteenth century. “Marvellous Melbourne” saw itself as the natural centre of any united Australia. Sydney saw things differently.
The colonies also disagreed about economic policy. Victoria favoured protectionism, with tariffs to shelter local industry; New South Wales favoured free trade. Federation would require compromises on all of this, and the location of the capital became one of the most symbolic.
Section 125: the compromise in the Constitution
The Australian Constitution, drafted at a series of conventions during the 1890s and approved by voters in the colonies, settled the question with a carefully worded clause. Section 125 states that the seat of government shall be determined by the Parliament, shall be within territory granted to or acquired by the Commonwealth, and shall be in the State of New South Wales, “but distant not less than one hundred miles from Sydney”.
It was a classic political trade. New South Wales got the capital in its territory. Victoria got assurance that it wouldn’t be in Sydney. The section also provided that Parliament would sit in Melbourne until it could meet at the new seat of government.
So when the Commonwealth of Australia came into being on 1 January 1901, its parliament began meeting in Melbourne, in the Victorian Parliament House on Spring Street. The Victorian parliament moved to the nearby Royal Exhibition Building. Nobody expected the arrangement to last long. In fact, it lasted twenty-six years.
Choosing a site
Finding the site proved difficult. Towns across southern New South Wales lobbied to be chosen, and parliamentarians toured candidates including Albury, Armidale, Bombala, Dalgety, Lake George, Lyndhurst, Orange, Tumut and Yass. Each had supporters and detractors. Considerations included climate, water supply, access to Sydney and Melbourne, scenery and potential for defence.
In 1904 Parliament passed a Seat of Government Act choosing Dalgety, near the Snowy River in the far south of the state. New South Wales objected, partly because Dalgety was so far from Sydney and so close to the Victorian border. After further debate, a second Seat of Government Act in 1908 replaced Dalgety with the Yass-Canberra district.
The surveyor Charles Scrivener was given the job of identifying a specific site within the region. His brief was romantic as well as practical: the capital should be a “beautiful city, occupying a commanding position, with extensive views”. He recommended the Limestone Plains, a broad valley crossed by the Molonglo River and ringed by hills. In 1909 New South Wales agreed to transfer the land, and on 1 January 1911 the Federal Capital Territory, later renamed the Australian Capital Territory, formally came into being.
In 1915 the Commonwealth added a small area at Jervis Bay on the coast, intended to give the capital access to the sea. That enclave remains federal territory today.
The land before the capital
The Limestone Plains weren’t empty. Ngunnawal people, along with neighbouring groups including the Ngambri and Ngarigo, had lived in and moved through the region for tens of thousands of years. The name Canberra is generally said to derive from a local Aboriginal word, often recorded as “Kanberra” or “Canberry”, commonly translated as “meeting place”, though its exact origins and meaning are debated.
From the 1820s, European pastoralists took up land in the district, establishing large sheep and cattle properties. By the time the Commonwealth arrived, the area had a scattering of homesteads, a church (St John’s, completed in the 1840s and still standing) and a small rural population.
A design competition and two Chicago architects
The new government wanted a capital that would announce the ambitions of a young nation, and in 1911 it launched an international competition for the city’s design. It attracted 137 entries.
The winner, announced in 1912, was Walter Burley Griffin, an architect from Chicago. His entry was produced in close partnership with his wife, Marion Mahony Griffin, also an accomplished architect, whose striking renderings on linen helped win over the judges. Historians now generally recognise the design as a joint achievement.
The Griffins’ plan used the surrounding landscape as part of the design. Their city was organised around geometric axes linking hills, including a land axis running from Mount Ainslie through Capital Hill and a water axis along a lake formed by damming the Molonglo River. Civic, administrative and residential areas were laid out in a pattern of circles, triangles and radiating avenues, with generous space for parks and trees. It was influenced by the City Beautiful movement and the Garden City movement, both popular among planners at the time.
On 12 March 1913, at a ceremony on the slopes of what’s now Capital Hill, Lady Denman, wife of the Governor-General, announced the city’s name: Canberra. The day is still celebrated as Canberra Day.
Slow construction
Building the capital was a far longer process than anyone had hoped. Walter Burley Griffin was appointed Federal Capital Director of Design and Construction but clashed repeatedly with officials who doubted his plans or wanted to change them. His position was abolished in 1920, and he and Marion moved on to other work, including in Sydney and later India.
The First World War diverted money and attention. Then came debates about budgets and priorities. Progress was patchy, and for years Canberra was a scattering of buildings and roads on open grassland, sometimes mocked as “a good sheep station spoiled” or “a city without a city”.
The decisive moment came on 9 May 1927, when the Duke of York, later King George VI, opened the Provisional Parliament House, a white building intended to serve for about fifty years. The federal parliament moved from Melbourne, and public servants began to follow, though many government departments remained in Melbourne for decades.
Growing into a capital
The Depression and the Second World War slowed growth again. Canberra’s real expansion came after the war. In 1957 the National Capital Development Commission was established with powers and funding to build the city. Within a few years, the long-planned lake was created. The Scrivener Dam was completed in 1963, and Lake Burley Griffin filled the following year, finally realising one of the central features of the Griffins’ design.
Key national institutions followed: the National Library, the High Court, the National Gallery, and in 1988 the new Parliament House, built into Capital Hill at the heart of the Griffins’ plan, opened for the Bicentenary. Canberra developed planned new towns such as Woden, Belconnen, Tuggeranong and Gungahlin, connected by parkways and separated by bushland, giving the city its distinctive spread-out character.
The ACT gained self-government in 1989, with its own Legislative Assembly, although the Commonwealth retains control of national land and institutions.
Was it the right choice?
Canberra has long been the butt of jokes, called sterile, dull or a city of roundabouts and public servants. Politicians sometimes use the word “Canberra” as shorthand for a bureaucracy out of touch with the rest of the country.
Yet the city has defenders, and their case has grown stronger. Canberra consistently ranks well on measures of liveability, income and education. Its relatively small size, abundant parkland and proximity to bushland appeal to many residents. Its national institutions, including the Australian War Memorial and the National Gallery, draw large numbers of visitors.
As for the original problem, the compromise worked. A purpose-built capital avoided giving permanent advantage to either Sydney or Melbourne, and it has given the nation a seat of government that belongs to all the states rather than to one. Other federations made similar choices. Washington, D.C., Ottawa and Brasília were all chosen or built partly to avoid elevating one powerful city over another.
So why is Canberra the capital of Australia? Because two cities couldn’t agree, and because a group of founders decided the answer was to build something new. The result took longer and cost more than anyone expected. But it gave Australia a capital designed from the start to be a symbol of the nation, laid out around hills, water and an idea of what a federation could be.
Best Essays is an independent publication. Essays are researched and edited by our editorial team; see our editorial policy. Spotted an error? Email info@bestessays.com.au.