Why did the Roman Empire fall? The long argument over history's most famous collapse
Invasion, plague, civil war, money troubles or climate? Historians have offered hundreds of reasons why the Roman Empire fell. Here are the ones that hold up best.
In 1984 the German historian Alexander Demandt published a list of every explanation he could find for the fall of the Roman Empire. It ran to 210 entries, alphabetised, from Aberglaube (superstition) to Zweifrontenkrieg (war on two fronts). Lead poisoning was on it. So were bureaucracy, celibacy, decadence, gout, homosexuality, hedonism, inflation, monasticism and a decline in the will to live.
The list was partly a joke at the expense of his own profession, but it made a serious point. The fall of Rome has been used to explain, and to warn about, almost anything. Each generation reads its own anxieties into it. Asking why the Roman Empire fell is really asking several questions at once: what fell, when, and what we mean by “fall”.
First, which empire?
The phrase usually refers to the Western Roman Empire. By the late fourth century, the empire was being governed in two halves, an arrangement that became permanent after the death of the emperor Theodosius I in 395, when his sons divided the administration between them. The western half was ruled from Milan and later Ravenna; the eastern half from Constantinople, the city Constantine had founded as a new capital in 330.
The eastern empire didn’t fall in the fifth century at all. It survived, prospered at times and lasted another thousand years until Constantinople fell to the Ottoman Turks in 1453. Its people called themselves Romans throughout. Historians later dubbed it the Byzantine Empire, but that’s a modern label.
So the question is really why the western half collapsed while the eastern half endured. Framed that way, some of Demandt’s 210 explanations immediately look weak. Christianity, decadence and lead pipes were present in both halves, and the east didn’t fall.
The traditional date
The conventional end date is 476 CE, when a Germanic general called Odoacer deposed the teenage emperor Romulus Augustulus and, rather than install a replacement, sent the imperial regalia to Constantinople. He ruled Italy as a king, nominally under the eastern emperor.
At the time, few people seem to have treated this as an earth-shattering event. Rome itself had been sacked by the Visigoths under Alaric in 410 and by the Vandals in 455. The western emperors of the preceding decades had mostly been puppets of powerful generals, and much of the western territory had already passed to Visigoths, Franks, Burgundians, Vandals and others. 476 marks the end of an office more than the end of a world.
The classic answer: Gibbon
The most famous account is Edward Gibbon’s The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, published in six volumes between 1776 and 1789. Gibbon’s prose is magnificent and his scholarship was formidable for its time. His central argument, crudely summarised, was that Rome declined because of “the triumph of barbarism and religion”.
Gibbon thought Christianity had sapped Roman civic virtue by turning attention to the next world, diverting talent into the church and dividing the empire with theological disputes. He also emphasised the corrupting effect of long peace and luxury, and the empire’s increasing reliance on barbarian soldiers.
Modern historians admire Gibbon but mostly reject his emphasis on religion. The eastern empire was at least as Christian as the west and survived. And the late Roman state was, by many measures, more effective than its predecessors at raising taxes and fielding armies, not less.
Pressure on the frontiers
The most widely accepted modern explanations put external pressure at the centre, while asking why Rome couldn’t absorb it as it had before.
The empire had always had enemies on its borders. What changed in the late fourth century was the scale and organisation of those pressures. Around 370, the Huns moved westward from the steppe, displacing Gothic groups north of the Danube. In 376 large numbers of Goths sought refuge inside the empire. Mismanagement and exploitation by Roman officials provoked a revolt, and in 378, at the Battle of Adrianople, the Goths destroyed an eastern Roman army and killed the emperor Valens.
From then on, substantial armed groups operated inside imperial territory, sometimes as allies, sometimes as enemies, often as both in turn. Rome tried to manage them through treaties, settlements and hiring their warriors. Over time those groups became kingdoms. The historian Peter Heather has argued that the Huns, by pushing other peoples into the empire and then forming a powerful confederation themselves, set off a chain reaction that the western empire couldn’t withstand.
The loss of Africa
If there’s a single turning point in the economic story, many historians would choose 439, when the Vandals captured Carthage. The provinces of North Africa were among the richest in the western empire, and their grain and tax revenue were essential to feeding Rome and paying the army.
Without that revenue, the western government was trapped in a vicious circle. Less money meant fewer soldiers. Fewer soldiers meant more territory lost. More territory lost meant still less money. Attempts to retake Africa, including a huge joint east-west expedition in 468, failed disastrously.
The eastern empire, by contrast, kept its wealthiest provinces in Egypt, Syria and Anatolia largely secure through the fifth century, protected by Constantinople’s formidable position and walls. Geography gave the east breathing room the west never had.
Civil war and political instability
Rome’s enemies were often less dangerous than Romans themselves. The third century had already seen a period of near-collapse, usually called the Crisis of the Third Century, roughly from 235 to 284, when dozens of emperors and would-be emperors rose and fell, frequently murdered by their own troops. The empire temporarily split into three. It was saved by a series of soldier-emperors and by Diocletian’s sweeping reforms, which enlarged the army and bureaucracy and reorganised taxation.
But the habit of usurpation never went away. Throughout the late fourth and fifth centuries, ambitious generals and regional commanders repeatedly launched bids for power. Each civil war drew troops away from the frontiers and consumed resources. Barbarian groups were frequently drawn in as allies of one Roman faction against another, gaining leverage and territory in the process. In the west, real power drifted to military strongmen such as Stilicho, Aetius and Ricimer, who ruled through figurehead emperors.
Disease and climate
In recent decades, historians have paid more attention to environmental factors. The historian Kyle Harper, in The Fate of Rome (2017), argued that pandemics and climate change played a major role in the empire’s troubles.
The Antonine Plague, which began around 165 CE, probably smallpox, may have killed a significant share of the population. Another epidemic, the Plague of Cyprian, struck in the mid-third century during the crisis. Most dramatically, the Plague of Justinian, beginning in 541, was caused by the same bacterium responsible for the later Black Death and devastated the eastern empire just as it was attempting to reconquer the west.
Harper and others also point to evidence from tree rings, ice cores and other natural archives suggesting that a relatively warm and stable climate during the early empire gave way to cooler, more erratic conditions, including a sharp cold period in the sixth century following volcanic eruptions. These ideas are still debated, particularly how strongly climate translated into political events, but they’ve widened the conversation beyond emperors and battles.
Fall or transformation?
From the 1970s, some historians, notably Peter Brown, began describing this period not as a “fall” but as “late antiquity”, an era of transformation in religion, art, law and society. In this view, Roman culture didn’t vanish; it was absorbed and adapted by the new kingdoms, which often kept Roman law, used Latin and saw themselves as heirs to Rome.
That perspective was a valuable corrective, but it has itself been challenged. In The Fall of Rome and the End of Civilization (2005), the archaeologist Bryan Ward-Perkins assembled evidence of a sharp material decline in the west: fewer coins, poorer pottery, smaller cattle, simpler buildings and a dramatic drop in the scale of trade. For ordinary people, he argued, the end of the western empire meant a real collapse in living standards that took centuries to recover.
Most historians now accept something of both views. Cultural and religious life continued and changed in creative ways. The economic and political structures that had held the western Mediterranean together did break down.
So why did it fall?
There’s no single cause, and anyone who offers one should be treated with suspicion. The most persuasive accounts combine several factors: a period of intense external pressure triggered by movements of peoples on the steppe; the loss of key revenue-producing provinces, especially North Africa; chronic political instability and civil war that turned Roman armies against each other; the strategic disadvantages of the west compared with the better-protected and wealthier east; and environmental shocks from disease and a changing climate that weakened the system’s ability to recover.
The western empire didn’t die of old age or moral decay. It was a large, complex state that had survived many crises before, until a cluster of them arrived together and its margin for error ran out. That is perhaps the most unsettling lesson of the story, and the reason people keep returning to it. Empires rarely fall because of one dramatic failure. They fall when problems that could each have been managed start to compound faster than anyone can respond.
Best Essays is an independent publication. Essays are researched and edited by our editorial team; see our editorial policy. Spotted an error? Email info@bestessays.com.au.