Why do we yawn? What science knows about the body's most contagious reflex
Yawning isn't about getting more oxygen. Why we yawn, why yawns are contagious, what brain cooling has to do with it, and when frequent yawning is worth noticing.
Try to read this essay without yawning. It may already be too late. Simply reading or thinking about yawning is enough to trigger one in many people, which tells you something about how odd this everyday reflex is.
Almost every vertebrate yawns, from humans and chimpanzees to dogs, cats, birds, snakes and fish. Babies yawn in the womb. We yawn when we’re tired, when we’re bored, when we wake up and, curiously, when we’re about to do something demanding, like run a race or perform on stage. And we yawn when we see others do it.
For something so common, yawning has proved surprisingly hard to explain. The most popular explanation, the one many of us learned at school, turns out to be wrong. Here’s what science knows about why we yawn.
Anatomy of a yawn
A yawn is more than a big breath. It follows a characteristic sequence. The mouth opens wide, the jaw stretches, and you take a long, deep inhalation. The muscles of the face, throat and often the whole body stretch at the same time; the eyes may close or water, and the eardrums can be pulled taut, briefly muffling hearing. At the peak there’s a pause, followed by a shorter, faster exhalation as the muscles relax.
The whole thing typically lasts around six seconds. Once a yawn begins, it’s very hard to stop halfway, which is why researchers describe it as a stereotyped action pattern, a fixed sequence that runs to completion once triggered.
Humans begin yawning remarkably early. Ultrasound studies have recorded yawning in fetuses from around the end of the first trimester. That alone suggests yawning is deeply built into our biology, rather than being a learned social habit.
The oxygen myth
The textbook explanation used to be that we yawn to take in extra oxygen or get rid of excess carbon dioxide, particularly when we’re tired and breathing shallowly.
It’s an intuitive idea, but experiments in the 1980s by the psychologist Robert Provine, one of the pioneers of yawning research, failed to support it. Provine and colleagues had volunteers breathe air with raised levels of carbon dioxide, or pure oxygen, and measured how often they yawned. Breathing extra carbon dioxide made people breathe faster and more deeply, but didn’t increase yawning. Breathing pure oxygen didn’t reduce it. Exercise, which strongly changes breathing and blood gases, didn’t alter yawning rates either.
The conclusion was that yawning and breathing are controlled by separate mechanisms. Whatever yawning does, regulating oxygen isn’t its main purpose.
The brain-cooling hypothesis
One of the most influential modern explanations is that yawning helps cool the brain. It was developed by the psychologist Andrew Gallup and colleagues from the late 2000s.
The brain is sensitive to temperature, and it works best within a narrow range. According to this hypothesis, a yawn acts like a radiator. Stretching the jaw increases blood flow to the skull, and the deep inhalation of air that’s typically cooler than the body draws heat away from blood flowing to the brain. The rush of fresh blood and cool air together could slightly lower brain temperature.
Several lines of evidence support the idea. In one study, people who held a cold pack to their forehead yawned less while watching videos of others yawning than those holding a warm pack or nothing at all. People who breathed through their nose, which cools incoming air and nearby blood vessels, also yawned less. Studies in rats have found brain temperature rises just before a yawn and falls afterwards.
Perhaps the most intriguing finding concerns the weather. Gallup’s research found that people yawned more in moderate temperatures than in very hot or very cold conditions. The explanation offered is that yawning cools the brain only when the air is cooler than the body; in extreme heat, air near body temperature can’t cool anything, and in severe cold, cooling isn’t needed. One study found people yawned more in winter than in summer in a hot, dry climate, consistent with this “thermal window”.
The brain-cooling hypothesis isn’t universally accepted, and the effects measured are modest. But it explains several puzzling observations, including why we yawn when tired (brain temperature tends to change around sleep and waking) and when stressed or about to perform (when brain activity is high).
Yawning as a state change
Another perspective treats yawning as a signal that the body is shifting between states: from asleep to awake, from alert to drowsy, from bored to attentive. Seen this way, a yawn helps rouse the brain, briefly increasing alertness by stretching muscles, boosting heart rate and changing blood flow.
This fits the common experience of yawning while trying to stay awake during a dull meeting or a long drive. It also explains why athletes, musicians and parachutists often report yawning just before a performance or jump. They aren’t bored; their bodies are preparing for a transition.
The state-change and brain-cooling explanations aren’t mutually exclusive. Both describe yawning as a way of resetting the brain for what comes next.
Why yawns are contagious
The most curious thing about yawning is its contagiousness. Seeing, hearing, reading about or even thinking about a yawn can trigger one. Studies typically find that a substantial proportion of adults, often around half or more, will yawn in response to watching videos of others yawning.
Spontaneous yawning appears in the womb, but contagious yawning develops later. Most children don’t show it reliably until around the age of four or five, roughly when they begin to develop more sophisticated social understanding.
That timing helped inspire a popular idea: that contagious yawning is linked to empathy. Several studies found that people yawned more in response to family members and friends than to strangers, and some research suggested contagious yawning was less common in people with certain conditions that affect social interaction. Brain-imaging studies have linked watching yawns to activity in regions involved in social processing and imitation.
The empathy link has proved less tidy than first hoped. A 2014 study by researchers at Duke University, which tested several hundred people, found that age was the strongest predictor of contagious yawning, with older people less susceptible, and that measures of empathy explained very little of the variation between individuals. The researchers concluded that contagious yawning probably isn’t a simple test of empathy.
Even so, the fact that contagious yawning is stronger between people who know each other suggests social bonds play some role. One idea is that it helps synchronise behaviour within a group, so that when one member becomes drowsy or alert, others follow, coordinating rest and vigilance.
Animals catch yawns too
Contagious yawning isn’t unique to humans. Chimpanzees and bonobos yawn in response to seeing others yawn, more so with familiar group members. Some studies have found that dogs yawn in response to human yawns, especially their owners’, although results vary between studies. Contagious yawning has also been reported in species including wolves, elephants and budgerigars.
In some animals, yawns serve other purposes as well. In baboons and some other primates, a wide yawn displaying large canine teeth can be a threat. In fish and snakes, yawn-like gaping may help realign the jaw or prepare for feeding. The basic action may be ancient, with different species adapting it over time.
Can you stop a yawn?
Mostly, no. Because a yawn is a stereotyped action pattern, attempts to stifle it usually produce a strangled half-yawn that feels unsatisfying, and often a second yawn soon after. A few tricks seem to reduce contagious yawning, at least a little. Breathing in through the nose, or putting something cool against the forehead, fits the brain-cooling account and has reduced yawning in experiments. Looking away from someone who is yawning helps too, since seeing a face mid-yawn is one of the strongest triggers.
Covering your mouth when you yawn is a social convention rather than a biological necessity. In many cultures it is considered polite, and historically some cultures associated yawning with danger, believing the open mouth might let a spirit escape or enter. Today a yawn in a meeting is usually read as boredom, which is unfair. As the research shows, it is just as likely to mean your brain is working hard to stay switched on.
When frequent yawning is worth noticing
For most people, yawning is harmless. Yawning a lot usually means you’re tired, bored or haven’t slept well.
Occasionally, though, excessive yawning can be a sign of something else. It can be associated with sleep disorders such as sleep apnoea or narcolepsy, side effects of some medications, and, more rarely, problems affecting the brain or the vagus nerve. If you notice a sudden, marked increase in yawning that isn’t explained by tiredness, especially alongside other symptoms, it’s worth mentioning to a doctor.
A reflex that still keeps secrets
Yawning has gone from being dismissed as a trivial quirk to a genuine scientific puzzle that touches on brain temperature, arousal, social bonds and evolution. The oxygen theory has been retired. Brain cooling and state change are the leading explanations. Contagious yawning remains partly mysterious, linked to social closeness but not simply to empathy.
If you’ve yawned while reading this, you’re in good company. Most people who read about yawning end up doing it, and scientists still aren’t entirely sure why.
Best Essays is an independent publication. Essays are researched and edited by our editorial team; see our editorial policy. Spotted an error? Email info@bestessays.com.au.