What is tall poppy syndrome, and is Australia really guilty of it?
Tall poppy syndrome is the urge to cut high achievers down to size. Where the idea comes from, why Australians are said to have it, and what the research shows.
Tall poppy syndrome is the tendency to resent, criticise or undermine people who are seen to have risen above everyone else: the successful, the wealthy, the famous, or simply the noticeably ambitious. The image is of a field of poppies in which any flower that grows taller than the rest is lopped off so that the field stays level.
Australians often describe it as a national trait, sometimes with a wince and sometimes with something like pride. New Zealanders claim it too. Business leaders complain that it discourages ambition, while others argue it’s really a healthy suspicion of arrogance. To understand what tall poppy syndrome is, it helps to separate the phrase from the behaviour, and the behaviour from the myths that have grown up around it.
An ancient metaphor
The image of cutting down the tallest stalks is far older than Australia. The best-known version comes from the Roman historian Livy, writing in the late first century BCE. He tells of Tarquinius Superbus, the last king of Rome, whose son Sextus had taken control of the town of Gabii and sent a messenger asking what to do next. The king, unwilling to trust the messenger with words, walked silently through his garden striking off the heads of the tallest poppies with a stick. The messenger reported this strange behaviour, and Sextus understood: he executed or exiled the leading men of Gabii.
An earlier version appears in Herodotus, where the tyrant Thrasybulus of Miletus, asked for advice by Periander of Corinth, walks through a wheat field cutting off the tallest ears of grain. Aristotle refers to the same story in his Politics as an illustration of how tyrants keep power by removing anyone prominent enough to challenge them.
In these ancient versions, notice who is doing the cutting. It isn’t the jealous crowd; it’s the ruler, eliminating rivals. The modern meaning has flipped the story around, so that it’s the ordinary people who cut down the exceptional. That inversion tells you something about how the idea came to be used.
How it became Australian
“Tall poppy” entered Australian political language in the early twentieth century, often to describe people who were highly paid or socially prominent. In 1931, during the Great Depression, the New South Wales Premier Jack Lang was widely reported as promising to cut down the “tall poppies”, meaning the high salaries of senior public servants. It was a populist pitch for fairness in hard times rather than a complaint about envy.
Over the following decades the phrase shifted from describing the privileged to describing the reaction against them. By the 1980s, “tall poppy syndrome” was firmly established as a name for a supposed national habit of knocking successful people. Its spread coincided with a period when Australian business and celebrity culture were becoming more visible and more international, and when some high-profile figures felt the local press was keen to see them fail.
The idea fitted neatly with older stories Australians tell about themselves: the egalitarian bush ethos, the dislike of “big-noting” and “skiting” (boasting), the suspicion of anyone who “gets above themselves”, and the convict-era resentment of authority. Many cultures have a version of it. Scandinavians talk about the Law of Jante, from Aksel Sandemose’s 1933 novel, which lists rules such as “You’re not to think you are anything special”. In parts of the English-speaking world people talk about “crab mentality”, after crabs in a bucket pulling down any that try to climb out. Australia’s version simply came with a particularly memorable image.
What the research says
Much of what’s said about tall poppy syndrome is anecdote. There is, however, a body of psychological research, much of it begun by the Australian social psychologist Norman Feather from the late 1980s, that tried to measure attitudes towards high achievers.
The findings are more nuanced than the cliché. People generally don’t resent success as such. What they react to is how it was achieved and how the successful person behaves. Feather’s work suggested that people were more pleased to see a high achiever fall when the success seemed undeserved, or when the person was seen as arrogant or self-promoting. When success was seen as earned through effort and ability, and worn with modesty, people tended to approve of it. People’s own sense of self-worth also mattered: those who felt they had less status were somewhat more likely to enjoy a tall poppy’s fall.
That pattern overlaps with what psychologists call schadenfreude, pleasure at another’s misfortune, which is often strongest when the misfortune seems deserved. It also overlaps with ordinary concerns about fairness. Seen this way, part of what gets labelled tall poppy syndrome isn’t envy at all but a reaction against people who are seen to have cheated, inherited advantage or behaved badly.
Surveys of workers and business owners do find that many people report experiencing it. Research on women in leadership, for instance, has found many respondents saying their achievements were downplayed or attacked at work. That is real, and it’s damaging. But it’s hard to show that Australians are measurably worse in this respect than people in comparable countries, because most of the evidence comes from self-report, and few studies compare countries directly.
The case against the poppy cutters
Critics of tall poppy syndrome argue that it has genuine costs. If success attracts hostility, people may hide their ambitions, play down achievements or leave altogether. Australia has a long history of talented people building careers overseas, and some of them have cited a sense that ambition was viewed with suspicion at home as part of the reason.
There’s also a problem of where the line falls. Healthy scepticism of a politician’s boasts can slide into reflexive mockery of anyone doing something new. Online, the dynamics can be harsher: public figures, especially women, often face pile-ons that go well beyond criticism of their work. Calling all of this “just a bit of a laugh” or “keeping people grounded” can excuse behaviour that is simply cruel.
In workplaces, it can show up as colleagues dismissing a co-worker’s results, managers taking credit, or an unspoken rule that no one should stand out. Organisations that want to encourage initiative have reason to notice that pressure.
The case for a little levelling
Defenders of the Australian attitude offer a different reading. They argue that what outsiders call tall poppy syndrome is often a culture’s refusal to be impressed by status for its own sake. In this view, the instinct to deflate pomposity has helped keep Australian public life relatively informal and has made it harder for elites to take public deference for granted.
Australians, the argument runs, are perfectly happy to celebrate excellence. Sport is the obvious example. Athletes who win and remain humble are adored; it’s the boastful or entitled ones who get cut down. The same goes for business figures and celebrities. What’s being policed isn’t achievement but a particular way of displaying it.
There’s some support for this in the research. If attitudes depend heavily on perceived modesty and deservingness, then the “syndrome” may be less about levelling everyone and more about a strong cultural norm against self-promotion. That norm has costs and benefits, and they fall differently on different people.
A useful phrase, used carelessly
One problem with the term is that it’s easy to wield as a shield. A business figure facing legitimate criticism, or a celebrity caught behaving badly, can dismiss their critics as tall poppy cutters, as if all scrutiny of the powerful were envy in disguise. That use turns the original Roman story back on its head again: the people in charge invoking the image to protect themselves from those below.
It’s more useful to treat tall poppy syndrome as a family of behaviours than as a single disease. Some of them are corrosive: sneering at effort, undermining colleagues, punishing difference. Some are healthy: asking how someone got where they are, refusing to treat wealth as a measure of worth. Distinguishing between them is harder than declaring that Australians have, or don’t have, a syndrome.
Growing tall without getting cut
For anyone who feels on the receiving end, the research offers a practical, if slightly frustrating, insight. Reactions to success depend a great deal on whether it seems earned and on how it is presented. Acknowledging help, being open about the work involved and avoiding the language of superiority tend to soften the response. That’s not fair to people who shouldn’t have to downplay what they’ve done, but it reflects how attitudes actually work.
For everyone else, the question is worth turning inward. When someone does well, the urge to find fault can be strong. Asking whether that urge is about their behaviour or about our own sense of falling behind is a small but useful habit.
Tall poppy syndrome, in the end, is a story Australians tell about themselves, and like most such stories it’s partly true, partly exaggerated and endlessly argued over. The image of the field of poppies endures because it captures a real tension in any society that values both equality and achievement. Getting that balance right isn’t a matter of cutting nobody down. It’s a matter of knowing which poppies have earned their height.
Best Essays is an independent publication. Essays are researched and edited by our editorial team; see our editorial policy. Spotted an error? Email info@bestessays.com.au.